HomeNew YorkNew York › Gotham Coffee Roasters

Gotham Coffee Roasters

4.4 ★★★★☆ 289 Google reviews · Coffee roastery · Cafe · Coffee shop

Roasts in-house Wholesale SubscriptionsSingle OriginEspresso roasts in-housegreat espressofresh pastriesfriendly baristascozy atmosphere

Trendy coffee shop serving artisanal coffees & pastries in a cozy, black-&-white establishment.

Visit

23 W 19th St
New York, NY 10011

(212) 255-2972

Directions Website

Instagram · Order beans online

Hours

Monday 7 AM–6 PM
Tuesday 7 AM–6 PM
Wednesday 7 AM–6 PM
Thursday 7 AM–6 PM
Friday 7 AM–6 PM
Saturday 9 AM–5 PM
Sunday 9 AM–5 PM

Where to find Gotham Coffee Roasters

What's in the cup

What Gotham Coffee Roasters is pouring and bagging — straight from customers' own reviews, not our guesswork.

📦 Subscriptions

All subscriptions roasters →

🌍 Single Origin

“The Mexico is exceptional and always my favorite whenever it is the single origin in stock.”

All single origin roasters →

Espresso 4 mentions

“Fantastic coffee shop with nice staff and great espresso.”

All espresso roasters →

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 289 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🔥 roasts in-house 2 mentions

“You can taste the freshness of their coffee drinks because their beans are roasted right here in NYC.”

great espresso 2 mentions

“Fantastic coffee shop with nice staff and great espresso.”

🥐 fresh pastries 6 mentions

“My daughter gave the chocolate croissant a 👌🏻and the cappuccino was “mid” My mocha was good, but I think if used a different milk it would have been better.”

😊 friendly baristas 3 mentions

“And the baristas and staff make the place - always welcoming, know people by name, full of cafe tips and suggestions.”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 3 mentions

“The shop is small but charming and cozy - not a good place to park with your laptop but really great for a catch up with a friend if you can snag a table.”

What customers say

Hands down the best coffee in all of New York! Gotham Coffee Roasters is a must visit for all real coffee drinkers. You will not be disappointed! I order all of my coffee beans for home from their website. It gets delivered directly to my door freshly roasted and unlike anything else I can find.

★★★★★ — Ben, 2024-10

A NYC coffee gem!!! Their coffee is absolutely delicious…string, well-roasted and complex flavor. Atmosphere is cozy and exactly what you would hope for in a neighborhood coffee spot. And the baristas and staff make the place - always welcoming, know people by name, full of cafe tips and suggestions.

★★★★★ — Anita, 2026-05

Niche shop with a very quiet vibe against the background music. There’s a selection of coffee beans, coffee makers, and assorted goods for sale on the side and comfortable seating while you wait for coffee or relax.

★★★★☆ — Kevin, 2025-09

Love this place! Gotham Coffee Roasters has amazing coffee, super smooth and flavorful. Cozy NYC vibes, friendly baristas, and perfect for a quick coffee break or chill time. Definitely coming back! 💛☕

★★★★★ — Ekshitha, 2026-02

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 289 reviews →

Coffee roasters near Gotham Coffee Roasters

:3Coffee | Flatiron

4.6 ★★★★★ 114 reviews

29 W 21st St, New York, NY

Roasts in-house great espressofresh pastriescozy atmosphere

Cozy shop featuring coffee and tea plus Colombian pastries such as empanadas, arepas, and pan de bono.

under a mile away

Irving Farm Coffee

4.1 ★★★★☆ 671 reviews

71 Irving Pl, New York, NY

Roasts in-house pour-over barcold brew on tapcozy atmosphere

Hip local coffee house chain serving light eats & drinks made from house-roasted beans.

under a mile away

Variety Coffee Roasters

4.4 ★★★★☆ 952 reviews

261 7th Ave, New York, NY

Roasts in-house great espressofresh pastriesEspresso

under a mile away

All coffee roasters in New York, NY →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.