HomeNew YorkNew Paltz › Dry Fly Coffee Company

Dry Fly Coffee Company

4.5 ★★★★★ 220 Google reviews · Coffee shop

Wholesale Espresso fresh pastriescozy atmosphere

Sun-drenched, artful coffee shop and bakery featuring hot drinks, avocado toast and baked goods.

Visit

87 N Chestnut St
New Paltz, NY 12561

+1 845-633-8703

Directions Website

Instagram · Order beans online

Hours

Monday 8 am–4 pm
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 8 am–4 pm
Thursday 8 am–4 pm
Friday 8 am–4 pm
Saturday 8 am–4 pm
Sunday 8 am–4 pm

Where to find Dry Fly Coffee Company

What's in the cup

What Dry Fly Coffee Company is pouring and bagging — straight from customers' own reviews, not our guesswork.

Espresso 4 mentions

“We recommend the woodland sourdough, the avocado toast with egg, the tomato toast and their special beverages from shaken espressos to espresso based with botanicals.”

All espresso roasters →

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 220 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🥐 fresh pastries 5 mentions

“I have been going here for a year or so and the pastries, tea and coffee have all been consistently great!”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 6 mentions

“The crew behind the counter were kind and the vibe was relaxed. This is a great place to get work done with adequate space or have a conversation without blaring music.”

What customers say

Great ambiance, tasty food made by passionate people is the summary of dry fly coffee company. From the amazing bread kneaded and baked on the spot, to the tasty and thoughtful takes on popular toast, and last but most importantly the unique coffee creations.

★★★★★ — Mohamed, 2023-08

Great place right off the bike/trail in New Paltz. Shared an avocado toast (Meyer lemon puree made this the best toast I’ve had since whoever invented avocado toast) and double espresso and latte. Open and bright yet small enough to be cozy. Lots of bicyclists and runners too.

★★★★★ — Maureen, 2024-06

Got an avocado toast and the lemon puree is just an amazing touch, that makes it probably the best avocado toast I‘ve ever eaten. Also got a cortado and enjoyed it a lot due to the light roast! Definitely will come back if I‘m in the area!

★★★★★ — Thomas, 2025-06

Only light roast coffee available but have ceramic cups so it was a good compromise as I prefer dark roast for espresso. Digital work atmosphere and sound track.

★★★★☆ — Richard, 2026-05

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 220 reviews →

Coffee roasters near Dry Fly Coffee Company

Gunks Gaming Guild Cafe

4.7 ★★★★★ 174 reviews

17 Church St, New Paltz, NY

Roasts in-house fresh pastries

Cozy hangout for coffee, pastries and other snacks alongside 150 board games.

under a mile away

Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters

4.6 ★★★★★ 410 reviews

10 Main St #312, New Paltz, NY

Roasts in-house

Relaxed cafe featuring house-roasted coffee and tea blends in a cozy setting.

under a mile away

Mercurial Coffee Co

4.9 ★★★★★ 72 reviews

87 Haviland Rd, Highland, NY

Roasts in-house Wholesale roasts in-houseSingle OriginEspresso

Hyper-small-batch roaster with a tiny espresso cart, serving tailor-made coffee drinks.

7.3 miles away

All coffee roasters in New Paltz, NY →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.