HomeOklahomaTulsa › PonyCoffee

PonyCoffee

4.8 ★★★★★ 239 Google reviews · Coffee shop

Espresso roasts in-housefresh pastriesfriendly baristascozy atmosphere

Laid-back coffeehouse dispensing custom-roasted blends and lattes alongside baked goods and more.

Visit

1623 S Main St
Tulsa, OK 74119

Directions Website

Hours

Monday 6:30 am–5 pm
Tuesday 6:30 am–5 pm
Wednesday 6:30 am–5 pm
Thursday 6:30 am–5 pm
Friday 6:30 am–5 pm
Saturday 6:30 am–5 pm
Sunday 6:30 am–2 pm

Where to find PonyCoffee

What's in the cup

What PonyCoffee is pouring and bagging — straight from customers' own reviews, not our guesswork.

Espresso 5 mentions

“The Coffee was so rich of espresso flavor.”

All espresso roasters →

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 239 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🔥 roasts in-house

“This shop roasts their own beans and offers $10 refills.”

🥐 fresh pastries 4 mentions

“I’ve come to love Pony Coffee and their gluten free muffins…which are the best muffins ever, gluten or no.”

😊 friendly baristas 3 mentions

“Coffee is amazing and the baristas are hard workers and are super nice!”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 6 mentions

“Shops have been either too corporate, cramped and sterile without that true "third space" feel or they've had the cozy atmosphere but with bad coffee and not enough space.”

What customers say

The Coffee was so rich of espresso flavor. I am cyclist and the first thing I like to do is get my cup of espresso before my ride. I was very pleased and you can’t compare this to Starbucks. I did research around all coffee shops and so glad I came in at 6:30 A.M. You see atmosphere outside their door.

★★★★★ — Brian, 2025-11

Great coffee shop with an inviting atmosphere, kind service, and good coffee. This shop roasts their own beans and offers $10 refills. There are plenty of places to sit, and the wifi works well.

★★★★★ — Sierra, 2024-12

Very interesting atmosphere but I could vibe with it. Was passing by and picked up a coffee. One barista was working alone, but she did great. A very simple menu, but great quality beans.

★★★★★ — Hosam, 2025-04

This place feels like stepping into a Christmas Hallmark movie. I stopped by with my husband (we don't live in Tulsa) and was blown away by the quality of the coffee, and the cozy atmosphere. I wanted to stay all day. Also, I grabbed a bag of their beans, and they have made some great cups of coffee.

★★★★★ — Kate, 2026-01

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 239 reviews →

Coffee roasters near PonyCoffee

DoubleShot Coffee Co

4.4 ★★★★☆ 1,157 reviews

1633 S Boulder Ave, Tulsa, OK

Roasts in-house Wholesale pour-over barfresh pastriessubscriptions

Independent cafe featuring house-roasted beans, craft drinks & light bites in comfy industrial digs.

under a mile away

Gypsy Coffee House

4.6 ★★★★★ 1,481 reviews

303 M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Tulsa, OK

fresh pastriescozy atmosphere

Late-night Arts District hangout with vegan dishes, WiFi & open-mike night in quirky warehouse digs.

1.5 miles away

Topeca Coffee Roastery

4.9 ★★★★★ 20 reviews

1229 E Admiral Blvd, Tulsa, OK

Roasts in-house Wholesale classes & cuppingssubscriptionsFair Trade

1.6 miles away

All coffee roasters in Tulsa, OK →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.