HomeIndianaFishers › Geist Coffee Company

Geist Coffee Company

4.8 ★★★★★ 310 Google reviews · Coffee shop

Wholesale cold brew on tapfresh pastriesships nationwidefriendly baristascozy atmosphere

Cozy coffee shop serving fresh-made breakfast foods and pastries, as well as some lunches.

Visit

10110 Brooks School Rd
Fishers, IN 46037

+1 317-516-4938

Directions Website

Instagram · Facebook · Order beans online

Hours

Monday 7 am–5 pm
Tuesday 7 am–5 pm
Wednesday 7 am–5 pm
Thursday 7 am–5 pm
Friday 7 am–5 pm
Saturday 7 am–5 pm
Sunday Closed

Where to find Geist Coffee Company

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 310 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🧊 cold brew on tap 2 mentions

“Had a bit of a wait due to them changing out the nitro, and then our other latte was picked up by accident.”

🥐 fresh pastries 6 mentions

“Amazing quality for coffee, drinks, and scones.”

🚚 ships nationwide 2 mentions

“Sometimes it gets so busy that the line is outside the door but I would recommend you order online to skip the line and pick it up inside or drive through widow.”

😊 friendly baristas 3 mentions

“Plus, the wifi connection is very good, the staff are very friendly and the coffee is great.”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 4 mentions

“It’s super nice and cozy inside, with plenty of seating, though it’s usually full, which just shows how much the locals love it.”

What customers say

Geist Coffee Company in Fishers offers a cozy atmosphere with friendly, knowledgeable staff. Even the owner is humble and shared the journey of this cafe. Their diverse coffee selection includes rich dark roasts and lighter, floral options, all consistently well-crafted with smooth textures and balanced flavors.

★★★★★ — Nitish, 2025-02

Lovely location, very warm and welcoming decoration inside. It's been a struggle to find well brewed local coffee since moving from Lafayette, but Geist fills that void. Great tasting espresso that stands up by itself. Friendly staff, great service, and great barista skills from the staff.

★★★★★ — Emily, 2018-12

Great coffee, good food. Had a latte with oat milk. The beans used were really tasty and the latte was made very well 🥛 to ☕️ ratio. It has a nice little outdoor seating area, as well as a nicely decorated interior. A good place to either spend some time or have a coffee and a chat.

★★★★★ — Alec, 2021-07

Colombian roast is best coffee I’ve ever had, love the atmosphere and great service! Outdoor seating for when the weather is nice!

★★★★★ — Elliott, 2024-04

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 310 reviews →

Coffee roasters near Geist Coffee Company

Brickhouse Coffee Company

4.8 ★★★★★ 1,222 reviews

9771 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN

Roasts in-house Wholesale fresh pastriessubscriptionsfriendly baristas

Casual, modern cafe with friendly service, roasting its own beans and serving a signature vanilla latte.

3.6 miles away

Qahwah House Coffee - Fishers Indiana

4.5 ★★★★★ 313 reviews

11680 Commercial Dr #800, Fishers, IN

fresh pastriescozy atmosphereCuppings & Classes

3.8 miles away

Nature Brew'd Coffee

1 ★☆☆☆☆ 1 reviews

11793 Technology Ln, Fishers, IN

Roasts in-house

3.8 miles away

All coffee roasters in Fishers, IN →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.