HomeWisconsinMenomonee Falls › Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls

Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls

4.5 ★★★★★ 610 Google reviews · Coffee shop

EspressoCold Brew cold brew on tapfresh pastriescozy atmosphere

Coffeehouse offering breakfast sandwiches and baked goods in a historic house with a rooftop patio.

Visit

1893 Appleton Ave
Menomonee Falls, WI 53051

+1 262-252-9003

Directions Website

Instagram · Facebook · Order beans online

Hours

Monday 6:30 am–7 pm
Tuesday 6:30 am–7 pm
Wednesday 6:30 am–7 pm
Thursday 6:30 am–7 pm
Friday 6:30 am–7 pm
Saturday 7 am–7 pm
Sunday 7 am–7 pm

Where to find Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls

What's in the cup

What Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls is pouring and bagging — straight from customers' own reviews, not our guesswork.

Espresso 3 mentions

“I get their espresso beans weekly, and they are always the freshest and work perfectly in my machine.”

All espresso roasters →

🧊 Cold Brew 3 mentions

“I ordered a cold brew with Oat Milk, and while I could tell that the coffee was high quality, it was not as strong as cold brew coffee should be.”

All cold brew roasters →

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 610 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🧊 cold brew on tap 3 mentions

“I ordered a cold brew with Oat Milk, and while I could tell that the coffee was high quality, it was not as strong as cold brew coffee should be.”

🥐 fresh pastries 4 mentions

“The cinnamon roll was light and airy, perfectly sized with the perfect amount of sticky, gooey cinnamon filling.”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 7 mentions

“Also it’s a bit hidden, Fiddleheads Coffee offers a delightful coffee experience with its cozy ambiance and carefully crafted brews.”

What customers say

I love coming here. The staff at this location are exceptional and personable - I’ve even had them remember I like all my drinks half-sweetened! I get their espresso beans weekly, and they are always the freshest and work perfectly in my machine. The rewards program is great and I often get $5 off my bag of beans.

★★★★★ — Gracie, 2025-06

Stopped here on our way from Milwaukee to Appleton in search of a coffee shop that wasn’t a big chain. Right off the bat, the environment was nice. The place is nicely furnished and has plenty of seating (inside and outside) to accommodate larger groups.

★★★★☆ — Ryan, 2022-08

I’ve loved this coffee shop for years and it continues to be one of my favorite places to relax. The atmosphere and overall style are beautiful — it feels warm, inviting, and thoughtfully designed. It’s the kind of place you genuinely want to sit and stay awhile.

★★★★☆ — Flower, 2026-02

Stopped here to kill time before work. This was my first time in a fiddleheads cafe in general. All the employees here were so nice and friendly and seemed to recognize some regulars. My food was good. I got a sausage, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich in an English muffin and I swapped the cheese to cheddar.

★★★★★ — Ciandria, 2026-01

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 610 reviews →

Coffee roasters near Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls

Latitude Cafe Roasting Co. - Menomonee Falls Library

4.5 ★★★★★ 32 reviews

W156N8436 Pilgrim Rd, Menomonee Falls, WI

Roasts in-house friendly baristas

under a mile away

Latitude Café Roasting Co. - Germantown

4.7 ★★★★★ 560 reviews

W156N9636 Pilgrim Rd, Germantown, WI

Roasts in-house roasts in-housefresh pastriesships nationwide

Neighborhood cafe serving coffee, smoothies, and all-day breakfast and lunch in a comfortable space.

1.2 miles away

6.3 miles away

All coffee roasters in Menomonee Falls, WI →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.