HomeNew YorkEast Aurora › Elm Street Bakery

Elm Street Bakery

4.7 ★★★★★ 1,193 Google reviews · Coffee roastery · Bakery · Breakfast restaurant

Roasts in-house fresh pastriescozy atmosphere

Seasonal American cuisine is served in this airy, rustic-chic cafe/bakery with a brick oven.

Visit

72 Elm St
East Aurora, NY 14052

(716) 652-4720

Directions Website

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 7:30 AM–4 PM
Thursday 7:30 AM–4 PM
Friday 7:30 AM–4 PM
Saturday 8 AM–4 PM
Sunday 8 AM–2 PM

Where to find Elm Street Bakery

What regulars say again and again

The things that keep coming up across 1,193 Google reviews — with a reviewer's own words as proof.

🥐 fresh pastries 6 mentions

“We tried a muffin, an almond croissant and a pecan sticky bun.”

🛋️ cozy atmosphere 10 mentions

“The vibe was amazing, everybody was so chill and welcoming, and the whole place just had such a cozy, laid-back atmosphere.”

What customers say

I heard about this place from work and went with my Mom for lunch today. This was our first time here and definitely not the last! The atmosphere was welcoming, the service helpful and the food delicious! We got cappuccinos and they were delicious and had pretty art.

★★★★☆ — Jennine, 2023-11

I’ve gone to Elm Street Bakery twice now, brought my partner with me the second time and have told no less than 15 people that they need to stop in if they’re in the area. I feel like I’m walking into a movie set when I come here. It’s just so quaint and lovely.

★★★★★ — S, 2025-10

The breakfast sandwich was good but I was not expecting it to be pre-made and cold. The hot tea was nice and high quality but it's always better if they give you a little plate to put your tea bag on for once it's done steeping. Otherwise, kind staff, bustling atmosphere, and good variety of items.

★★★★☆ — Emma, 2026-02

Was taken on a surprise breakfast date and this place was super cute! We went on a weekend and it was very busy with people and families constantly coming in and out. Ordered a couple breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and a latte. Wish the sandwiches were warmed up (maybe we just had to ask?

★★★★★ — Mai, 2023-04

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 1,193 reviews →

Coffee roasters near Elm Street Bakery

Majestic Hill Coffee Roasters

86 E and West Rd, West Seneca, NY

Roasts in-house

8.8 miles away

Premium Coffee Company

4.8 ★★★★★ 367 reviews

2510 Hamburg Turnpike, Buffalo, NY

Roasts in-house Wholesale roasts in-housecold brew on tapEspresso

12.4 miles away

Great Lakes Coffee Roasters

4.7 ★★★★★ 225 reviews

123 Stutzman Rd, Bowmansville, NY

Roasts in-house Wholesale great espressocold brew on tapfresh pastries

Coffee shop featuring single-origin beans and specialty drinks, plus tea and pastries.

12.6 miles away

All coffee roasters in East Aurora, NY →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and customer reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this roastery? Claim your listing — it's free.